Preface from Irene van der Zande, Kidpower founder and Executive Director:
In my horror over the mass murder in Isla Vista near Santa Barbara, and grief for everyone harmed by this terrible tragedy, I have been struggling with what to say. Our Kidpower North Carolina Center Co-Director and my “Doing Right by Our Kids” Co-Author Dr. Amy Tiemann has written the powerful insightful article below that transforms paralysis into understanding.
Although there are a few sad exceptions, as in any profession, I have found most law enforcement officers to be compassionate people who care a great deal about the public good and do the best they can under very difficult circumstances. I believe that most failures to stop tragic outbursts of mass murder and other violence are NOT the fault of our police officers. They are often caught between conflicting demands – of stopping violence without trampling on civil rights – of investigating a concern without clear guidance on what to check for and how to check within legal boundaries, support and education from mental health experts, and information from other social systems involved with this person, including families who are worried about this person being on a destructive path that is a danger to others. There are many social factors we need to work on for the long run such as those described by Amy below – and, for the short run, we also need a far better coordinated response that treats individuals whose actions seem to be heading towards violence with fairness and compassion while taking effective action to assess the risk of threats and intervene when necessary. – Irene
Republished with permission; this post by Amy Tiemann, Phd, was originally published on the “Doing Right by Our Kids” website on May 26, 2014:
My grief about Elliot Rodger’s Santa Barbara killing rampage takes me to an almost wordless place. But I think it’s important to find my voice and try to address it.
Two distinct perspectives on the topic of masculinity and socialization came together today that make sense to me.
It just happens that today was the day that I needed to watch a TEDx talk by Joe Ehrmann of Coach for America. Ehrmann talks about three words that are one of the most culturally destructive mandates in this country: “Be a man.” Ehrmann says that the typical socialization of masculinity involves massive repression, separating boys’ heads from their hearts. You can see some of what Ehrmann calls the “myths of masculinity” in Elliot Rodger’s violent manifesto he put out before undertaking mass killings. The myths are: 1. Size, strength and athletic ability define a man. 2. Sexual conquests, using women to validate yourself, define a man. And, 3. Economic success is key to masculinity.
Ehrmann wants us to rewire and reframe what it means to be a man, recasting sports in a positive way to help this effort. This will take rewiring and reprioritization of sports teams as a set of relationships working toward a common purpose, in a way that curates the trust, respect, integrity and dignity of all team members.
The first voice that immediately came to mind when I heard about Rodger’s massacre was Carol Lee Flinders, a writer who takes on the intersection of feminism, spirituality, and politics. She makes it clear that in the gender wars there are no real winners. A piece from her book At the Root of This Longing has stuck in my mind from the day I read it, over ten years ago. She was writing about the murderer Richard Allen Davis, who in 1993 snatched 12-year old Polly Klaas from her home and killed her, but Flinders could just have well have been writing about Elliot Rodger when she wrote:
What I felt I could not ignore…was the basic shape of these crimes–this one crime. This was not violence in general or in the abstract, it was violence in a particular and concrete form: a man overpowering and then destroying a young woman with whom he has absolutely no acquaintance. No emotional nexus, no drug deal gone awry, no personal score to settle….Each of those girls had been deeply cherished, not as a possession or asset, but for the vibrant, lovely, intelligent being that she was and for all the promise her life held. But in the eyes of the man who destroyed her, she was absolutely nothing. She was, in fact, an object–a thing. Here was the logical endpoint of that process I’d seen traced out by feminist historians that began when women and girls first became negotiable tender. It was with enormous reluctance that I came to believe I had to read these deaths no merely as acts of violence in an increasingly violent culture, but as crimes committed by men against women.
Flinders connects these murders to our larger system:
I had come to see Polly Klaas’ death as a real watershed, because I simply could not look at it, as I once might have, in isolation. Its resemblance to the only two other violent deaths that had touched my life was just not to be denied. The truth that forced itself upon me now involved a connection that I’d been close to making for some time but had resisted. It was that the men who deal out violence upon women and children–the rapists, the kidnappers, the molesters, the pornographers–are the unacknowledged but systematically groomed “enforcers” of a system of values and priorities that it seemed to me inaccurate to identify as anything but patriarchy.
What scares me most about Elliot Rodger’s murderous rampage is this: he was not railing against our social script like an anarchist Unabomber–instead, Rodger was sitting in his BMW, making YouTube videos, preparing to acting out our social script with explosive, deadly intent. Despite ample warning signs of mental instability and impending violence, we were not able to stop him. I wonder if the police didn’t take the warnings about Rodger more seriously because he was following our social script–so from what they knew of him, he didn’t seem too far outside of normal. The police were steps away from discovering Rodger’s gun stash when they visited his apartment in April, but Rodger talked them into thinking he was okay. (This huge failing to stop Rodger in April when they had the chance will undoubtedly be the subject of an ongoing investigation. It appears that police had neither watched the disturbing YouTube videos that alarmed Rodger’s parents, nor did they check to see if he owned guns, before they visited him at his apartment.)
So where are we now? Shaking our heads and saying nothing can be done? Controlled by fear as always? Or do we have the courage to write a new script? This is a multi-generational effort, a social evolution and revolution that feels maddeningly slow. It’s as though we know better but we still cannot do better. But we have to keep trying.
Resources for Coping With Violence